Sofia frames herself as an independent powerhouse who never needed male management, claiming she was unfairly cast as the villain in Alex's polished docuseries narrative.
Insiders are buzzing about Sofia's direct accusation that Alex 'rolled over' for Dave Portnoy's deal, suggesting Alex prioritized ownership over their friendship and let Portnoy dictate the terms.
1. Alex Cooper's docuseries 'Call Her Alex' (June 2025) claimed Sofia rejected a $500k deal with ownership. 2. Dave Portnoy's memoir 'Cancel Me If You Can' admitted he leaked rumors about Peter Nelson to break their friendship. 3. Sofia's memoir 'Daddy Issues' drops Nov 10, 2026.
This isn't just a spat; it's a reclamation of the narrative. Sofia is proving that Alex's 'sisterly' betrayal story was missing a few key chapters about who really held the leash.
The receipts are out, and they are spicy. Sofia Franklyn, 34, is no longer staying quiet while Alex Cooper, 32, controls the narrative of their explosive breakup. In an exclusive clip for Amanda Hirsch’s “Not Skinny But Not Fat” podcast, set to air Tuesday, November 10, Franklyn dismantled Cooper’s version of events, specifically targeting the implication that male managers were pulling Franklyn’s strings.
“No dude is in my ear telling me what to do,” Franklyn stated firmly, directly challenging the subtext of Cooper’s recent media appearances. Franklyn pointed out the glaring inconsistency in Cooper’s storytelling. “Alex makes such a convincing YouTube video and she brings up Scooter Braun and she brings up my agent.
All these men are trying to run her show,” Franklyn noted. But then she flipped the script, dropping the bombshell accusation that Cooper was the one who capitulated to Barstool founder Dave Portnoy. “You literally ran to Dave and rolled over,” Franklyn claimed.
“You gave Dave what he wanted. Also none of those people were doing that [to me].” This isn't just a disagreement; it's a direct challenge to the victimhood Alex has cultivated since the split. To understand the weight of these claims, you have to look at the timeline.
The duo launched “Call Her Daddy” at Barstool Sports in 2018, but their friendship imploded during contract negotiations in 2020. Cooper’s 2025 docuseries, “Call Her Alex,” alleged that Franklyn refused a $500,000 deal that included show ownership, leaving Cooper to take the win. Cooper even claimed their relationship was “so awful” before the contract debacle, despite fans believing they were “like sisters.” But Portnoy, 49, spilled the real tea in his own memoir, “Cancel Me If You Can,” admitting he leaked rumors about Franklyn’s then-boyfriend Peter Nelson shopping the show to ensure the women hated each other.
“Alex and Sofia completely severed all communication. They each believed the other had leaked the story,” Portnoy wrote. Franklyn’s new memoir, “Daddy Issues,” hits shelves this Tuesday, serving as her official rebuttal.
She previously admitted on her “Sofia With an F” podcast that she developed a “hard exterior” out of fear after the drama, but she’s now ready to be open. By bringing up Portnoy’s manipulation and Cooper’s alleged submission to his terms, Franklyn is painting Cooper not as a sister betrayed, but as a businesswoman who chose ownership over loyalty. The internet might have seen “sexual and ditzy,” but Franklyn is proving she’s also sharp, strategic, and done being the punchline.