The Spin

The film is a true story about a real person, written on spec by Peter Gamble, making it a classic original biopic like ‘Milk’ or ‘Darkest Hour’.

The Tea

Insiders are whispering that because Rocky Balboa is iconic IP, the Academy might force it into the adapted category, repeating the controversial ‘Barbie’ move.

The Receipts

Deadline for Official Screen Credits is Nov. 12. ‘I Play Rocky’ earned $345,000 in its first seven theaters. The Writers Branch executive committee makes the final call, which is unappealable.

The Last Byte

Stallone’s legacy is safe, but his screenwriter’s Oscar chances are hanging on a technicality that could ruin the film’s awards momentum.

Sylvester Stallone famously wrote the original *Rocky* screenplay in just three days, but figuring out which Oscar category his new biopic, *I Play Rocky*, belongs in is taking the industry much longer. Amazon MGM Studios’ latest awards contender is currently stuck in a bureaucratic tug-of-war, with the studio, the Writers Guild of America (WGA), and the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences all weighing in on whether Peter Gamble’s script is an original or adapted work.

As of November 10, no determination has been made, leaving the film’s awards trajectory dangerously uncertain just days before the final submission deadline. The core of the dispute lies in the fact that while Gamble wrote the script on spec as an original work—meaning it wasn’t based on a book, article, or single published source—it deals with pre-existing characters like Rocky Balboa, Adrian, and Apollo Creed. The film, directed by Peter Farrelly, restages scenes from the 1976 classic, leading some insiders to argue it fits the adapted category, which is reserved for scripts built on previously established material.

This isn’t unprecedented territory; in January 2024, Greta Gerwig’s *Barbie* was moved to adapted after Warner Bros. and the WGA had campaigned it as an original, ultimately resulting in a nomination but a loss to *American Fiction*. Farrelly, who won Best Picture and Original Screenplay for *Green Book*, is now navigating similar treacherous waters. Complicating matters further is the procedural gap left by the WGA.

Although Gamble is a guild member, *I Play Rocky* was not produced under a WGA signatory agreement, meaning the guild cannot officially classify the screenplay for its own awards or the Academy’s. This leaves the decision entirely in the hands of the Academy’s Writers Branch executive committee, which has the authority to break from WGA classifications. The committee’s guidelines state that films are generally deemed adapted if they use pre-existing characters, but they are considered original if they tell a true story based on the writer’s own research.

The committee’s ruling is final, with no appeals allowed, and the verdict likely won’t surface until nominations voting opens in January 2027. The stakes are incredibly high because both screenplay races are stacked with heavy hitters. If the film is classified as original, Gamble will face off against contenders like Jesse Eisenberg for *The Debut* and Martin McDonagh for *Wild Horse Nine*.

If it’s moved to adapted, he’ll be up against Christopher Nolan’s *The Odyssey* and Denis Villeneuve’s *Dune: Part Three*. Meanwhile, the film is gaining momentum in other areas, having opened in seven theaters on November 6 with a strong $345,000 gross and winning the Audience Choice Award at Cinéfest Sudbury. But in the Oscar game, a category shuffle can kill a campaign, and *I Play Rocky* is currently playing a dangerous game of chicken with Academy tradition.

📰 Sources

Variety

📷 Dominik Bindl · Getty Images