Jenner's legal team claims these cases are a publicity stunt by a single attorney seeking an unwarranted payday, promising to defend against the meritless claims vigorously.
Insiders are whispering about a pattern of bizarre behavior, from staff being locked in closets to being forbidden from smiling, suggesting a toxic work environment behind the glamour.
Lawsuit filed Nov. 5; Amaya claims she was locked in a closet for over an hour in 2025; fourth lawsuit in seven months; all plaintiffs represented by attorney Della Shaker.
When four different employees sue for similar reasons in seven months, it’s not just a legal battle—it’s a brand crisis waiting to explode.
Kylie Jenner’s household is officially the hottest legal drama in Hollywood, and the receipts are getting messy. A former housekeeper, Dinora Carolina Cabria Amaya, filed a lawsuit in Los Angeles Superior Court on Nov. 5, marking the fourth time in just seven months that a former household employee has taken legal action against the Kylie Cosmetics founder. The allegations are not just about unpaid wages; they paint a picture of a workplace that sounds straight out of a horror movie.
Amaya claims she was bitten by a dog, accidentally exposed to pepper spray, and trapped inside Jenner’s closet for more than an hour while a supervisor laughed at her pleas for help. This isn't just a slip-up; it’s a pattern that is rapidly turning Jenner’s domestic staff into her biggest critics. The details of Amaya’s complaint are as bizarre as they are disturbing.
She alleges that she began working for Jenner in March 2025, earning $40 an hour in cash, but was routinely denied overtime pay and required to travel between properties without mileage reimbursement. The most shocking incident occurred when Amaya claims she was instructed by supervisor Laura Dooley to enter Jenner’s closet using a passcode, only to become locked inside for over an hour. According to the court documents, Amaya called Dooley in a panic, begging for help, but Dooley allegedly laughed and mocked her, stating, “No one is at the house that can let you out and I cannot give the password to anyone else, you just have to wait.” Amaya was left trapped until someone eventually came to release her, a scenario that raises serious questions about the safety and dignity afforded to staff behind closed doors.
The alleged mistreatment didn’t stop at closet confinement. Amaya claims she suffered a workplace injury in September 2025 when an unsecured canister of pepper spray discharged into her eyes and face while cleaning a laundry room drawer, leaving her with blurry vision and constant irritation. The following month, she alleges she was bitten by a dog while cleaning a doghouse at one of Jenner’s properties, reporting the injury but receiving no meaningful assistance.
Instead, she says she had to purchase over-the-counter medication to treat herself. The situation allegedly worsened until she was fired on Feb. 6, shortly after questioning why another housekeeper was receiving mileage reimbursement while she was not. Her attorney, Della Shaker, framed the case as a broader issue, asking, “How many domestic workers are afraid to report unlawful treatment because they believe their employers are too powerful to challenge?” Jenner’s legal team, led by Michael Rhodes, is pushing back hard, arguing that these cases are being orchestrated by the same lawyer to extract an “unwarranted payday” through publicity.
“We’re not going to be intimidated into doing that,” Rhodes stated, vowing to defend the cases vigorously. However, the sheer volume and variety of the claims are difficult to ignore. Amaya’s lawsuit follows allegations from Angelica Hernandez Vasquez, who claimed she was mocked for her Salvadoran background and Catholic faith; Juana Delgado Soto, who alleged she was forbidden from looking at or smiling at Jenner; and a former private chef, identified as Jane Doe, who claims she suffered a miscarriage after working physically demanding shifts despite a high-risk pregnancy. All four women are represented by Shaker, and several lawsuits name the same companies and supervisors, creating a web of legal entanglements that Jenner’s PR team can no longer spin away with a smile.