The Spin

Tubi claims Paytas is the perfect fit for their audience, praising her 'bold, unfiltered storytelling' and loyal fanbase. They frame the show as a safe, fun space where queer love gets the big-platform representation it deserves.

The Tea

Insiders are whispering that hiring Natalie Shabtai, a producer from The Bachelor, is the real story here. Is this a genuine attempt at authentic queer representation, or just a way to package Paytas' chaotic energy into a familiar, formulaic reality TV structure?

The Receipts

Confirmed: 'Don't Date Alone With Trisha Paytas' premieres Feb. 4, 2027, on Tubi. Natalie Shabtai, former 'The Bachelor' producer, is signed on as showrunner. Episodes run 30 minutes.

The Last Byte

Trisha is trading her YouTube chaos for a scripted romance pipeline, and with a Bachelor showrunner at the helm, expect the drama to be engineered, not accidental.

Trisha Paytas is pivoting from YouTube controversies to hosting duties, and she is bringing some serious reality TV pedigree with her. The content creator has been tapped to host Tubi’s new unscripted dating series, *Don’t Date Alone With Trisha Paytas*. While the platform markets this as a wholesome celebration of queer love, the hiring of Natalie Shabtai as showrunner signals a shift toward polished, formulaic production.

Shabtai previously worked as a producer on *The Bachelor*, a franchise known for its manufactured drama and rigid structures. This pairing raises an immediate question: Can Paytas’ unfiltered, often chaotic brand coexist with a showrunner trained in the art of controlled narrative? The show’s premise relies heavily on the concept of friendship as a filter for romance.

Each episode features a best friend setting up their queer friend with three potential matches. Paytas and the best friend then guide the candidates through a series of "outrageous compatibility challenges" before selecting a winner for the blind date. In a statement to The Hollywood Reporter, Paytas emphasized the importance of this dynamic, stating, "It’s so hard for us as individuals to see red flags for ourselves, but it is much easier to spot them from a mile away for others." She framed the series as a "fun spin on a classic dating show," explicitly noting her desire to enlist professionals to ensure the execution matched her vision.

Tubi’s executive team is clearly banking on Paytas’ massive, if polarizing, social media presence to drive viewership. Rich Bloom, Tubi’s GM of creator programs, called her "exactly the kind of creator we want to be in business with," citing her "distinctive voice" and "deeply loyal fanbase." Bloom described the show as "hilarious, genuine and just a little over the top," suggesting that the network is leaning into the spectacle rather than shying away from it.

This marks a significant step for Paytas, who has recently expanded her acting resume with appearances in *Euphoria* and *Hacks*, further cementing her transition from internet personality to mainstream entertainment figure. Despite the PR spin about safety and representation, the involvement of a *Bachelor* veteran suggests the show may not be as raw or authentic as Paytas’ online persona implies. The series is executive produced by Wheelhouse’s Spoke Studios, with Courtney White, Jessica Zalkind, Gardner Reed, and Cassie Berman attached.

As Paytas herself admits, she wanted to create a show where everyone feels "safe and looked after," a far cry from the unregulated chaos of her podcast *Just Trish*. With a premiere date set for February 4, 2027, audiences will soon see if this calculated blend of queer romance and reality TV tropes can survive the scrutiny of Paytas’ most critical detractors.

📰 Sources

Hollywood Reporter

📷 Emma McIntyre · Getty Images