The Spin

The Academy highlights its record-breaking global membership of over 11,000 voters, arguing that a more diverse voting body naturally leads to more inclusive nominations if the films are seen.

The Tea

Insiders whisper that the 'buzz' for diverse performances is being stifled by late releases and lean campaigns, with distributors failing to spend enough to keep titles like 'Clarissa' and 'Josephine' in the conversation.

The Receipts

Gold Derby predictions in late October showed 9 of 10 lead acting slots going to white performers. The USC Annenberg report notes that in 2025, 30 top-grossing films had no Black characters, and women directed only 9 of 111 films.

The Last Byte

The talent is undeniable, but without aggressive campaigning and voter engagement, Hollywood risks a PR disaster that undoes years of incremental progress.

The ghosts of January 2015 are haunting the Dolby Theatre once again. While Michael B. Jordan’s historic Best Actor win for “Sinners” in March 2026 was celebrated as a turning point, new data suggests the industry is dangerously close to repeating the #OscarsSoWhite controversy.

According to Gold Derby’s aggregated predictions in late October, three actors of color held nomination spots across all four acting categories, yet not a single director of color made the projected five. In the lead acting races, nine out of ten slots were occupied by white performers, with Mexican-Australian breakout Inde Navarrette standing as the lone exception among the top contenders. If these trends hold through nominations morning on January 21, the Academy will face the same backlash that April Reign ignited eleven years ago.

The root of the problem lies upstream in Hollywood’s production halls, not just the voting booth. A recent study by the USC Annenberg Inclusion Initiative, “Inequality in 1,900 Popular Films,” reveals that while 41.5% of speaking characters in 2025’s top-grossing films came from underrepresented groups, significant gaps remain. Thirty films featured no Black characters, 46 had no Hispanic or Latino characters, and 26 had no Asian characters.

Behind the camera, the disparity is even starker: women accounted for only 33.6% of speaking roles, and just nine of the 111 directors were women, a figure identical to 2008 levels. This structural inequality means that despite a deep bench of talent, the films that could challenge the status quo are often released late or campaigned poorly, slipping out of the voters’ view. Key contenders like Zendaya and Colman Domingo are fighting against this momentum.

Zendaya, who has zero Oscar nominations despite her massive global fame, is being positioned by Warner Bros. for Best Actress for her role as Chani in “Dune: Part Three,” a shift from her supporting roles in previous installments. Meanwhile, Colman Domingo, already a historic nominee for “Rustin” and “Sing Sing,” sits on the bubble for Best Supporting Actor for “Michael,” the first biopic to cross $1 billion worldwide. Pedro Pascal, delivering what critics call the best performance of his career in Tony Gilroy’s “Behemoth!,” faces a tough road due to the film’s December 4 release date, which leaves little runway for voters to catch up.

Other names like Mahershala Ali in “Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother” and Jeon Do-yeon in Netflix’s “Possible Love” are similarly struggling to break into the consensus. The disconnect between critical acclaim and award predictions is glaring. Gemma Chan’s producer credit on “Josephine,” which won both the Grand Jury Prize and Audience Award at Sundance, has not translated into a supporting actress nomination push.

Similarly, James Ortiz, who voiced and puppeteered Rocky in “Project Hail Mary,” has been formally submitted by Amazon MGM but remains absent from prediction charts. The Academy’s expanded membership of over 11,000 voters, a quarter of whom live outside the U.S., is theoretically more inclusive, but it creates a logistical trap. A more diverse voting body cannot nominate films it hasn’t seen. With distributors holding back on aggressive campaigns for these diverse titles, the industry risks another year where the most celebrated performances are invisible to the voters who hold the gold statues.

📰 Sources

Variety

📷 Edward Berthelot · Getty Images