For Thug and Birdman, this is the ultimate vindication: a clean slate proving their hands were clean regarding the Wayne bus incident all along.
The plaintiff’s attorney, Jeff Gewirtz, isn’t backing down and plans to appeal, keeping the 2015 shooting saga alive despite the judge calling the claims against the rappers 'pure speculation.'
On Nov. 10, Judge Eric A. Brewton dismissed Jeffrey Williams and Bryan Williams from Alvin Lewis's 2016 lawsuit, citing 'no evidence of an employment relationship' with shooter Jimmy Winfrey.
Young Thug and Birdman just dodged a decade-long bullet, but the legal war over that 2015 tour bus shooting isn't over yet.
After a grueling ten-year saga that saw some of hip-hop’s biggest names tangled in Atlanta’s most notorious legal mess, Young Thug and Birdman have finally been dismissed from the civil lawsuit stemming from the 2015 shooting on Lil Wayne’s tour bus. Two Georgia court orders obtained by Billboard on Tuesday, November 10, officially removed Jeffrey Williams (Thug) and Bryan Williams (Birdman) from the case filed by former tour bus driver Alvin Lewis.
The decision marks a significant victory for the rappers, who have long maintained they had nothing to do with the drive-by incident that occurred on the I-285 freeway after a performance at The Compound club. The core of the lawsuit alleged that the shooter, Jimmy Winfrey (also known as Peewee Roscoe), was acting under the direction of Thug and Birdman. Lewis claimed Winfrey was Thug’s tour manager in 2015 and that Birdman orchestrated the attack to retaliate against Wayne for suing Cash Money Records.
However, Judge Eric A. Brewton wasn’t buying it. In his ruling, the judge stated there was “no evidence of an employment relationship” between Winfrey and either YSL or Birdman’s Cash Money Records.
He further dismissed the theory involving Birdman as “pure speculation and conjecture,” effectively shutting down the narrative that the rappers pulled the strings behind the violence. While Lewis’s legal team presented evidence of phone calls between Winfrey and Birdman on the night of the shooting, Judge Brewton found this insufficient. The judge noted he couldn’t determine “who made what calls, whether any calls were picked up and by whom, whether any conversation was had, or the content of any conversation.” This technical breakdown in evidence proved fatal to the claims against the two moguls.
The dismissal comes after Thug already walked free from the sweeping YSL racketeering prosecution, where the bus shooting was cited as one of several violent acts allegedly connected to his label. Despite the dismissal of Thug and Birdman, the case against other defendants remains alive. Lewis still has pending civil claims for emotional damages against Winfrey and Arnold Martinez, known as YSL Duke, who was also involved in the YSL gang prosecution.
Lewis’s attorney, Jeff Gewirtz, confirmed to Billboard on Wednesday, November 11, that they plan to appeal the judge’s decision to drop the rappers. With a court conference scheduled for February to discuss potential trial logistics, the drama surrounding that 2015 night on the I-285 continues to unfold, even if Thug and Birdman are finally off the hook for now.