Paramount frames this as a triumphant return of a beloved A-list icon, leveraging the meta-narrative of Scrooge’s redemption to mirror Depp’s professional revival.
Insiders suggest Depp is hiding behind the character to avoid accountability, with biographer Brian J. Robb noting the strategy protects him from 'searching questions about the recent past.'
Ebenezer projects a $20M domestic opening across 3,500 locations; Depp’s last studio role was dropped in 2018; Rotten Tomatoes score sits at 50%.
Depp is betting that nostalgia outweighs controversy, but refusing to address his past may limit his redemption arc to just one movie.
It is fitting, almost poetically so, that Johnny Depp returns to the big screen this weekend playing a man haunted by his past mistakes. After nearly a decade away from major studio features, following the tumultuous 2022 defamation trial with ex-wife Amber Heard and his 2018 dismissal from Warner Bros.' Fantastic Beasts franchise, Depp is finally back in the box office fray. Paramount Pictures is releasing Ebenezer, director Ti West’s adaptation of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, in more than 3,500 North American locations. The studio projects a domestic opening of $20 million, with another $20 million expected internationally, positioning it to likely claim the No. 1 spot at the North American box office against David Leitch’s How to Rob a Bank. The strategy behind this comeback is as calculated as it is cautious. Depp has participated in limited press opportunities, most notably appearing in character as Scrooge rather than as himself. This includes an unannounced, extended riffing session at a San Diego Comic-Con panel. At the London premiere earlier this month, when asked by the Associated Press about his hiatus from Hollywood films, Depp quibbled with the question’s wording before stating, “There was a bit of a vacation, which is fine,” before a publicist quickly whisked him away. Brian J. Robb, author of the 1996 biography Johnny Depp: A Modern Rebel, tells THR that this refusal to break character is a form of protection. “It’s a clever — if obvious — strategy,” Robb says, noting it shields Depp from uncomfortable questions while reminding fans of his immersive acting history. Paramount seems to be banking heavily on the power of nostalgia and international appeal. Adrian Daub, director of the Clayman Institute for Gender Research at Stanford University, analyzed millions of YouTube comments from the Depp v. Heard trial. He notes that many fans were swayed less by the specific facts of the case and more by “a general nostalgia for Depp roles of the early aughts,” such as Jack Sparrow and Edward Scissorhands. Daub points out that non-North American audiences, who did not track #MeToo in Hollywood as closely, are “much readier to move on,” suggesting the studio is targeting these demographics alongside domestic fans who miss the 2003 smash Pirates of the Caribbean era. However, critics argue that Depp is missing a golden opportunity to truly reconcile his public image. Ernest Owens, author of The Case for Cancel Culture, believes Depp could have embraced the Scrooge metaphor by acknowledging his “misguided” past to present a narrative of genuine reflection. “But you have to actually feel that way,” Owens says. “And I think Depp is not someone who actually thinks he did anything wrong.” With Ebenezer holding a 50 percent approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, despite a favorable THR review claiming it “fulfills its ostensible goal of restoring the actor to A-list status,” the jury is still out. Depp’s next step is Lionsgate’s Day Drinker, slated for March 2027, but whether he can follow the paths of Robert Downey Jr. or Mel Gibson remains to be seen if he continues to dodge the hard questions.