Merriman's camp likely argues these are private, out-of-context banter between friends, insisting the 'alleged' nature of the texts means nothing definitive proves wrongdoing or intent on that specific night.
Insiders and the internet are fixated on Wehbe's alleged quote about 'smashing' and getting rid of the women, viewing the texts as evidence of a callous environment that contributed to the tragedy.
TMZ obtained court docs showing texts from July 21, 2017. A jury previously awarded $4 million in wrongful death damages against Merriman and others. Fattorini died from an overdose involving alcohol, cocaine, and GHB.
These 'alleged' texts are the receipts that keep the $4 million judgment alive. Context is key, but the timing is damning.
The ghost of July 21, 2017, is haunting Shawne Merriman all over again. TMZ has obtained court documents revealing a series of alleged text messages exchanged between the former NFL star and nightclub promoter Elias Wehbe. The timing couldn't be worse for Merriman: these messages allegedly flew back and forth on the very day Playboy model Kimberly Fattorini died from a fatal overdose.
For anyone following this legal saga, these aren't just old texts; they are the fresh receipts Fattorini's parents are using to fight Wehbe's attempt to reduce a massive wrongful death judgment. The content of these alleged exchanges is what has the internet buzzing. According to the filings, Wehbe allegedly told Merriman he had three "whores" at his home, specifically naming Kimberly and two others.
But it's the next line that raises eyebrows: Wehbe allegedly wrote, "Nah I'm tryna get rid of them so I can smash." The texts further allege that Wehbe complained about the women not leaving and even asked Merriman to have another man text Kimberly to facilitate their departure. Wehbe also allegedly noted that someone was getting jealous, painting a picture of a chaotic, intoxicated environment hours before the tragedy. This isn't just gossip; it's legal ammunition.
Kimberly's parents, who sued Merriman, Wehbe, and others alleging their daughter was drugged before suffering the overdose, are using these texts to support the jury's original findings. Her death was ruled accidental, with toxicology reports confirming alcohol, cocaine, and GHB in her system. A civil jury previously found Merriman and the other defendants liable, resulting in a $4 million judgment.
Now, the family argues these specific text messages prove Wehbe helped arrange for their intoxicated daughter to leave his home with Merriman, reinforcing the liability established in court. Merriman has consistently denied any wrongdoing, but these alleged texts provide a granular look at the conversations surrounding Fattorini's final hours. The distinction between "alleged" and "proven" is the battleground here.
While the defense may argue these are private, out-of-context banter, the plaintiffs are leveraging them to show a pattern of behavior and intent. As Wehbe fights to reduce the financial payout, the spotlight is firmly back on what was said—and unsaid—between these men on the day Kimberly Fattorini's life ended.