The narrative is pure maternal instinct: a loving mother seeking to provide her daughter with a lifelong support system and sibling bond, framing the decision as an act of profound care rather than just family planning.
Insiders note the internal conflict: Shay admits Summer is currently in a jealous 'only-child phase' and refuses to share attention, creating a tricky dynamic between the child's current resistance and the parents' future-oriented fears.
Shay, 41, and Davies, 36, welcomed daughter Summer Moon Honey Davies on April 26, 2021. Shay revealed in July 2025 she suffered from HELLP syndrome, making surrogacy a likely path for a second child.
Scheana Shay isn’t just thinking about a baby; she’s planning for Summer’s future grief, turning a funeral moment into a family expansion catalyst.
Scheana Shay is opening up about the emotional catalyst behind her potential family expansion, and it’s rooted in a moment of profound vulnerability. During a recent episode of her "Scheananigans" podcast, the "Vanderpump Rules" star revealed that attending the funeral of a friend’s father earlier this year shifted her perspective entirely. Watching the friend’s children stand together at the service, Shay was struck by the realization that she wants her own daughter, Summer, to have that same support system when facing life’s inevitable losses.
"I just knew when that moment comes for Summer, I want her to have someone," Shay shared. "I don’t want her to be up there alone." This isn’t just idle chatter; it’s a concrete shift in the Shay-Davies household dynamics. Shay, 41, and her husband Brock Davies, 36, have been actively discussing adding to their family lately.
However, the path isn’t straightforward. Shay admitted she has been "back and forth" on whether to pursue another child, specifically weighing the option of using a surrogate. This hesitation stems from her traumatic experience with her first pregnancy, where she suffered from HELLP syndrome, a dangerous complication involving high blood pressure and liver issues.
Back in July 2025, Shay told Us Weekly that she "hadn’t fully come to terms" with the surrogacy option, worrying about the potential lack of biological connection to a second child. Adding to the complexity is Summer’s current developmental stage. The reality TV star noted that her daughter is firmly in the "only-child phase," where she actively resists sharing her mother’s attention.
"Summer does not want to share me," Shay explained, highlighting the immediate tension between her long-term desire for a sibling bond for her daughter and the present-day reality of a toddler who wants all the spotlight. Despite these hurdles, the couple is "slowly taking steps" toward the decision, indicating that while they aren’t ready to take the next step yet, the door is far from closed. The couple’s journey to this point has been closely watched.
They legally tied the knot in a secret ceremony in August 2021, shortly after Summer’s birth on April 26, 2021, before exchanging vows again in a destination ceremony in Cancun in August 2022. Shay’s recent comments suggest that while the logistics of surrogacy and the emotional hurdles of bonding are still being navigated, the core motivation has solidified: ensuring Summer never has to face the world’s hardest moments without a sibling by her side. It’s a poignant reminder that for many parents, the decision to expand the family is less about filling a house and more about securing a future support network for their children.