The Arnold sisters remain close as ever, with Rylee stepping confidently into the DWTS spotlight while supporting her older sister's future decisions. Lindsay's legacy as a two-time champion speaks for itself, and any potential return would be on her own terms.
Insiders note that Lindsay has been selective about public appearances since stepping back from DWTS. Sources say the 32-year-old dancer has been exploring other ventures, which may make a full-time ballroom return unlikely in the near future.
Rylee Arnold is 21 years old; Lindsay Arnold is 32. Rylee gave an exclusive interview to Us Weekly on Wednesday, August 5, 2026, discussing her sister's potential DWTS return and the possibility of both sisters competing on the same season.
The Arnolds have given DWTS fans plenty to discuss this week. Whether Lindsay ever returns to the ballroom remains uncertain, but Rylee is clearly carving out her own impressive path in the competition world.
Rylee Arnold may be following in her big sister's sequined footsteps on Dancing With the Stars, but when it comes to Lindsay making a comeback to the ballroom, even little sister isn't sure that's in the cards. In an exclusive conversation with Us Weekly on Wednesday, August 5, the 21-year-old professional dancer opened up about what it would actually take for her 32-year-old sister to lace up those famous dance shoes again—and the answer was refreshingly honest. "I don't know," Rylee admitted when pressed on Lindsay's future with the show. The younger Arnold has been making waves as a DWTS pro since joining the series, building her own reputation among fans and celebrity partners alike. While Lindsay established herself as a two-time champion during her tenure on the competition—winning seasons 18 and 27—Rylee has been focused on establishing her unique identity within the franchise. The sisters have long been compared to one another in the dance world, with Lindsay's early success naturally drawing attention to Rylee's arrival. But sources close to the family say there's no rivalry between them—just mutual support and genuine sisterly pride. "They talk constantly," one insider told Celebrity Bytes. "Lindsay has been Rylee's biggest cheerleader since day one." So what would prompt a Lindsay Arnold return? Rylee kept her cards close to the vest, suggesting that only time will tell whether fans might eventually see both Arnolds competing on the same season. For now, Rylee appears content to let her sister's career unfold organically, without pressure from the dance world or fans eager for a family reunion on the ballroom floor. It's a diplomatic answer from someone who's clearly learning the ins and outs of celebrity PR—but also one that hints at reality. Lindsay has been relatively private since stepping back from full-time competition work, and a return to DWTS would represent a significant pivot. Whether that happens remains to be seen, but Rylee's candor suggests the family isn't holding its breath for an announcement anytime soon.
